Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Jurén's avatar

I had to ask claude for an explanation of the low p/e on cyclicals, because that is counter-intuitive to what I was taught long ago. Claude explained and gave praise:

”The problem is structural:

When a cyclical company is at peak earnings:

- E is maximised

- P/E appears low — "cheap"

- But E is about to fall dramatically

- The "cheap" P/E is actually pricing in permanently high earnings that won't last

When a cyclical company is at trough earnings:

- E is minimised or negative

- P/E appears high or infinite — "expensive"

- But E is about to recover dramatically

- The "expensive" P/E is actually pricing in permanently low earnings that won't last

Trader Ferg and Gave are doing you a service by making this explicit. Most investors never figure it out.”

haaiFx's avatar

That Meb Faber tweet about dividend mutual funds, and the note about EM semiconductor exposure? My mind was blown twice in one short post.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?